On August 9, Union Minister for Women and Child Development Smriti Irani lashed out at Congress leader Rahul Gandhi for allegedly blowing a flying kiss in the Lok Sabha during the no-confidence motion debate. She called him a misogynist for his “indecent act”.
Some women MPs from the BJP lodged a complaint with Speaker Om Birla against Congress MP Rahul Gandhi, seeking “stringent action” for the “inappropriate gesture”. Their complaint alleged that the behaviour “not only insulted the dignity of the women members in the House but has also brought disrepute and lowered the dignity of this august House.”
As a woman, I am happy that women MPs in the 542-member Lok Sabha, where their number is way below 100, are coming together for a cause — to fight misogyny. But I would also like to see the women MPs and ministers stand up for all women in the country, irrespective of their caste, societal status or political allegiance; not just against a Congress MP.
The irony is that the uproar coincided with the outgoing Wrestling Federation of India (WFI) chief and BJP MP Brij Bhushan Sharan Singh telling a Delhi court, “Merely touching a woman without sexual intent doesn’t involve criminal activity…the event is a wrestling event…the coaches are mostly male. If out of anxiety or joy of doing something for the nation, a coach hugs his student, it shouldn’t be considered an offence”. The submissions were made as the court heard arguments on framing of charges against Singh and suspended WFI assistant secretary Vinod Tomar on sexual harassment charges by women wrestlers who brought laurels to the country but had to protest for months to bring their harassers to book.
Irani and her ministry were conspicuous in their silence in Singh’s case; as they were when women were raped and paraded naked in Manipur and when a family was fighting for justice in Hathras where a Dalit girl was raped and murdered in 2020.
Whether an average woman would find Rahul Gandhi’s blink-and-miss act a gesture of misogyny is highly debatable. It was definitely not a mature act for a parliamentarian but it also wasn’t as indecent a gesture as it is being made out to be. A caring hug, a peck on the cheek or a harmless flying kiss can be a warm gesture often.
A woman’s battle against misogyny, prejudices and hatred is not limited to an MP blowing a flying kiss in Parliament. She fights much fiercer battles in her daily life — on the street, in the discomforts of home, in office spaces, inside public transport or while labouring at construction sites and farms. Don’t belittle her fights by saying a flying kiss was the worst act of misogyny ever.
yamini.nair@expressindia.com