scorecardresearch
Monday, Aug 14, 2023
Advertisement
Premium

Can campaigns like Just Stop Oil achieve their real purpose if they fail to draw mass attention to it?

There’s no two ways about the fact that all nations have to do more for the environment. But change cannot happen overnight or under duress.

wildfireA local reacts as the flames burn trees in Gennadi village, on the Aegean Sea Island of Rhodes, southeastern Greece. (AP/PTI)
Listen to this article
Can campaigns like Just Stop Oil achieve their real purpose if they fail to draw mass attention to it?
x
00:00
1x 1.5x 1.8x

I don’t know quite what to make of the ‘Just Stop Oil’ protests going on in Europe and the UK recently. Groups of orange-clad protestors, linking arms and standing across roads and motorways blocking traffic. Or working in pairs or small numbers, disfiguring classic works of art in museums and interrupting major sporting events, like the recently-concluded Wimbledon.

They claim that they’re merely trying to draw attention to the major issue afflicting Earth at the moment: global warming due to the burning of fossil fuels. They don’t want their children and grandchildren to grow up in a toxic blast-furnace and suffer all the hideous consequences that come along with high greenhouse-gas levels and polluted air. Who does? So, one can understand and empathise with that. Europe and parts of America and Asia are experiencing temperatures once associated with tropical countries – and they have little infrastructure and traditional knowledge to deal with it.

But the trouble is that this mode of protest is not making the protestors – or worse – the cause popular. Sitting in a traffic jam four-hours long, your engine idling, is not doing any good to the environment. Apart from the risk of your engine boiling over, there’s the risk of your temper doing the same thing, especially if you have children to pick up, or someone to drop asap to a hospital, or urgent deliveries to make. This is already happening as furious drivers drag the somewhat po-faced protesters to the sides of the road only to have them promptly get back and resume their positions. The police – like so often happens here – are nowhere to be seen or will turn up when matters get ugly. Of course, we all have the right to protest, but not at the cost of stopping people going about their everyday lives.

There’s certainly no way any country is going to ‘just stop oil’ as if flipping a switch. We saw what happened when COVID-19 ‘just stopped’ our lives virtually overnight. Sure, it seemed to make the birds, animals and insects very happy because there was no one around to interfere with their lives. (And we saw and heard them more, simply because we had the time and there was no traffic background noise). But it wasn’t good for us. If there was anything we could learn from it, it was that if we were less of a nuisance to other creatures, we could get along with them quite nicely. Elephants in some national parks in Africa walk right up to tourist vehicles without wanting to smash and overturn them, because they know no harm is going to come to them. In India, you see a wild elephant, say in Corbett National Park and you run – because the animal’s previous experience with human-beings has been unpleasant.

There’s no two ways about the fact that we’ll have to back-pedal regarding the use of fossil fuels, but it cannot be overnight, or we’ll somersault over the handlebars! We could argue about the pace – that it needs to be faster, more urgent and better funded — but the transition has begun, and we need to keep at it vigilantly, demanding accountability at every turn. Throwing spanner in the works and inconveniencing people is less likely to achieve that.

If there is any authority that will put ginger up our tails, it is Nature Ma’am. She’s already beginning to crack the whip – what with forest fires blazing across Europe and Canada, smothering cities with the kind of pollution only New Delhi was notorious for. In our part of the world (lest we get too smug) there have been cloudbursts, avalanches, landslides and, of course, the great flooding of Delhi. It was a shock to find how in a matter of hours your entire life could be turned upside down! Of course, a big deal was made of the fact that some of the majorly affected sections of the Capital were the ‘posh’ areas where government officials live, but then Nature Ma’am doesn’t give a rat’s arse about such things – she’s apolitical!

Also Read
MIrza Ghalib, Ghalib Mazar, Mirza Ghalib poetry, Mirza Ghalib shayari, Mirza Ghalib couplets
Tota Roy Chodhury
sarojini naidu
konkona sen sharma

Like us, it looks like the rich, developed countries are now facing a purgatory of their own making and will hasten to scramble out of it. We in India, unfortunately can’t seem to be in more of a hurry to jump into it!  So, we do need to make a noise about it: but not by super-gluing ourselves to roads and stopping the lives of people or destroying great pieces of art. That’s just pissing on the cause!

First published on: 26-07-2023 at 12:40 IST
Latest Comment
Post Comment
Read Comments
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
close